Sugar Cookie

  • Sugar Cookie

Sugar Cookie

Available for in-store pickup. We require at least 5 days notice for all online orders so we can ensure your order is fresh and ready for you each and every time.

  • Soft and buttery, this homemade Sugar Cookie melts in your mouth! Peggy’s secret recipe, which includes real Wisconsin butter and Madagascar vanilla, shines in this cookie that can please even the most selective of palates.

    Sold as package of 1 (3-oz cookie).